What Does It Mean To Be A Woman without Children?
Reflections on identity, culture and the stories we inherit about a woman’s life.
Not long ago, I attended a baby shower for a friend preparing to become a mother for the first time.
The gathering was thoughtful and intimate. Each guest had been asked to bring a personal object or image as a way of wishing her peace and safety during labor. Later, the fifteen women in the room were invited to offer her a few words of wisdom.
Most were mothers. As we went around the room, they shared what pregnancy, birth, and raising their children had taught them. The closer we came to my turn, the more anxious I became. My thoughts began to tangle: What will I say? What wisdom can I possibly offer as a woman who isn’t a mother?
No one in the room had suggested that I had nothing to contribute. The invitation had been extended to all of us.
Yet I had instinctively begun measuring the value of what I might offer against an experience I had never had: motherhood.
In a room gathered to recognize one woman’s transition, I briefly lost sight of the transitions that had shaped me and of the wisdom they may have given me.
Why did the knowledge I had gained through my relationships, my work as a therapist, caring for people I love, navigating uncertainty, and becoming more fully myself feel less immediately available to me as a form of women’s wisdom?
I have come to believe that the answer has something to do with the stories we inherit.
THE STORIES WE INHERIT
Before we know who we will become, most of us inherit a story about what a woman’s life is supposed to be.
We absorb these stories from our families, faith traditions, communities, the media we consume, and the milestones our culture chooses to celebrate. Long before we are old enough to question these ideas, they can become a kind of psychological measuring stick against which we compare our own lives.
Across much of Western culture, a woman’s life has traditionally been understood through a series of recognized passages: puberty — coming of age, becoming a mother, and eventually becoming a grandmother.
We celebrate weddings. We gather for baby showers and new births. We honor mothers and celebrate when they become grandmothers for the first time. While these moments are, of course joyful, they do something more than commemorate an event.
They help us recognize that a woman’s identity has changed.
Anthropologist Arnold van Gennep introduced the term “rites of passage” to describe experiences that help people move from one stage of life into another. Whether marked by an elaborate ceremony, such as a wedding, or a familiar tradition, such as walking across a stage at graduation, these rituals serve an essential human purpose. In the presence of community, they communicate:
Your life has changed.
We see it.
We reflect back to you this new identified.
MATRESCENCE: THE SINGULAR STORY?
For women, one adult transition has received extraordinary cultural attention: motherhood.
Consider how many rituals surround becoming a parent, from pregnancy announcements, baby showers, and birth celebrations to Mother’s Day and the smaller family traditions passed from one generation to the next as mothers become grandmothers.
We even have language for the internal transformation involved. The term matrescence was first introduced in 1970s by Anthropologist Dana Raphael to describe the process of becoming a mother. The concept recognizes motherhood not simply as a biological event, but as a developmental passage that can reshape a woman’s identity, relationships, body, emotional life, and sense of self.
Once I began looking at motherhood through that lens, I found myself noticing something I had not fully seen before and asking a question I have been sitting with ever since.
WHEN THE CULTURAL MAP ENDS
What happens when motherhood – whether by choice or circumstance – is not part of a woman’s developmental arc?
What stories help her understand the person she is becoming?
What rituals or celebrations acknowledge the new versions of herself that emerge throughout adulthood?
Think about women you know, or even just you.
The women who have left marriages and rebuilt their lives from the ground up, made bold career changes, returned to school later in life, or become primary caregivers for aging parents. Think about women who have built businesses, crossed oceans alone, created families of friends, poured themselves into mentorship or creative work, and reinvented themselves more than once.
These experiences profoundly change a woman.
Yet there is seldom a moment when the people around her gather to acknowledge what has changed, what she has released, or who she has become.
Perhaps that was part of what I experienced at the baby shower?
I had been shaped by transitions of my own, yet I briefly treated motherhood as the measure of whether my experience counted as women’s wisdom. I was measuring myself against a developmental arc that wasn’t mine and in that moment, feeling inadequate.
THE LANGUAGE PROBLEM
For women whose lives do not include motherhood, there is no widely shared cultural framework that recognizes our adult arc as a full and wholly complete expression of womanhood.
Instead, we have inherited stories that define us according to how our lives have deviated from an “unexpected” path.
Think about the common tropes.
The Old Maid. The Spinster. The Crazy Cat Lady.
Even terms like childless, childfree, women without children, non-mothers words chosen to distinguish between very different experiences or offer solidarity, describe a woman in relationship to motherhood or the children she doesn’t have.
These distinctions may seem subtle, but I think they matter.
Language does not simply describe identity. It shapes the stories available to us.
When nearly every available identity begins with what is absent, it can quietly teach us to understand ourselves through absence too.
Over time, that framing can become a kind of low-grade shame—a felt sense of being less than, even when we consciously believe our lives are whole.
What language do we have for a woman’s growing self-knowledge, the relationships she has nurtured, the care she has offered, the things she has created, or the wisdom she has earned? How do we recognize the ways she has changed, not in relation to a role she did not occupy, but in relation to the life she has actually lived?
So, perhaps the most radical act is to reject the premise of absence altogether.
Its to have more places where we can see our lives mirrored back to us not as a departure from the story of a woman’s life, but life that’s fully whole and complete.
It is time for the cultural imagination to catch up.
Interested in exploring more questions like these?
A new virtual journey is coming.✨
Want to stay close to what we're building? Join the newsletter for writing that reflects the way we travel: with intention, and nothing surface-level.